25 films that defined the year, weighed across the polls that count
CE
Caleido Editorial TeamJuly 25, 202618 min read0 views
Some film years split the vote. 2025 did the opposite. By December the same handful of titles were sitting at the top of nearly every serious list in the world: Paul Thomas Anderson's One Battle After Another won the Sight & Sound international critics' poll, IndieWire's survey of 148 critics and Metacritic's ranking by review score, then took Best Picture at the 98th Academy Awards. It is rare for the most admired film of a year to also be its most propulsive.
What sat beneath the winner was more interesting than the winner. Ryan Coogler's Sinners proved that a genre picture built from Delta blues, vampires and Black history could be both the year's biggest original hit and its second most acclaimed film. Jafar Panahi took the Palme d'Or with a work made in defiance of a state that had imprisoned him. Kelly Reichardt, Bi Gan, Mascha Schilinski, Radu Jude and Dea Kulumbegashvili each made something formally uncompromising and each found an audience for it. Horror had its most decorated year in living memory — Weapons won an acting Oscar, which almost never happens to a film about a disappearance at 2:17 in the morning.
The other pattern was geographic. Brazil, Iran, Norway, South Korea, Georgia, Germany, China, Romania and Spain all appear in the twenty-five below, and not as tokens: The Secret Agent, Sentimental Value, No Other Choice and It Was Just an Accident competed for the same prizes as the American films and frequently beat them.
This list is a fusion, not one critic's opinion. Where the polls disagreed we favoured the film with the broader base of support rather than the loudest single advocate. A note on dates: films are placed by their primary release year, which is how Caleido dates them — a few titles that premiered at festivals in 2025 only reached audiences in 2026 and appear in our 2026 list instead.
Use the checklist below to track what you have seen, and what you still owe yourself.
Paul Thomas Anderson · Thriller, Crime, Comedy · ★ 7.3
Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Penn, Chase Infiniti
Paul Thomas Anderson turns Thomas Pynchon's paranoia into a chase film with a pulse: a burnt-out revolutionary played by Leonardo DiCaprio is dragged back into a fight he walked away from sixteen years earlier, with Sean Penn's grotesque colonel closing in. It swept the 98th Academy Awards — Picture, Director, Adapted Screenplay — and topped both the Sight & Sound poll and IndieWire's critics survey. The rare consensus choice that actually moves.
Ryan Coogler · Horror, Action, Thriller · ★ 7.5
Michael B. Jordan, Hailee Steinfeld, Miles Caton
Ryan Coogler's Mississippi Delta vampire picture is the year's best argument for the big screen: a 1932 juke joint where the music summons something older and hungrier than the men who came to kill for it. Michael B. Jordan plays both twins and won Best Actor; Coogler took Best Original Screenplay. Horror, musical and gangster elegy at once — and it refuses to choose, which is precisely the point.
Made after years of state harassment and imprisonment, Jafar Panahi's Palme d'Or winner follows a handful of former detainees who believe they have recognised their torturer and must decide what to do about it. The premise sounds like a thriller; the film plays as a moral comedy that keeps handing the audience the knife. Rueful, funny, and quietly devastating.
Joachim Trier · Drama · ★ 7.4
Renate Reinsve, Stellan Skarsgård, Inga Ibsdotter Lilleaas
Joachim Trier reunites with Renate Reinsve for the story of a director who tries to repair his relationship with his adult daughters by offering one of them a part in his comeback film. Cannes gave it the Grand Prix and the Academy gave it Best International Feature. Trier's gift is for the ordinary cruelty of families — and for the moment, always arriving late, when someone finally says the true thing.
Kleber Mendonça Filho · Thriller, Drama, Crime · ★ 7.2
Wagner Moura, Alice Carvalho, Gabriel Leone
Recife, 1977: a man arrives in a city that is not his, carrying a past the dictatorship would prefer closed. Kleber Mendonça Filho won Best Director at Cannes and Wagner Moura Best Actor, and the film operates simultaneously as paranoid thriller, civic history and ghost story about how a country remembers its own violence. One of the few titles to place top five in every major poll.
Kelly Reichardt · Drama, Crime · ★ 5.7
Josh O'Connor, Alana Haim, Hope Davis
Kelly Reichardt has made the least glamorous heist film imaginable, and means it as a compliment: a 1970s Massachusetts carpenter with vague artistic pretensions (Josh O'Connor) steals paintings, then has to live inside the consequences. No score swells, no plan snaps shut. Third on the Sight & Sound poll, and the year's finest study of a man learning that confidence and competence are different things.
Oliver Laxe · Drama, Thriller · ★ 6.9
Sergi López, Bruno Núñez, Stefania Gadda
Oliver Laxe sends a father and son into the Moroccan desert to find a daughter who vanished at a rave, then lets the search curdle into something close to apocalypse. It opens as a road movie and ends somewhere no synopsis survives. Fourth on the Sight & Sound poll and eighth in IndieWire's survey: the most argued-about film of the year, and the one people describe with their hands.
Eva Victor · Drama, Comedy · ★ 6.8
Eva Victor, Naomi Ackie, Louis Cancelmi
Eva Victor writes, directs and stars in a first feature about the years after an assault — not the event itself, but the long strange weather that follows it. The tone is the achievement: the film is frequently very funny and never once uses the humour to look away. A Metascore of 90 and top-ten placings across the polls made it the year's most assured debut.
Josh Safdie's first solo feature follows a table-tennis hustler with far more self-belief than luck, played by Timothée Chalamet at maximum velocity. The Safdie signature is intact — sweat, debt, rooms that keep getting smaller — but there is an unexpected tenderness toward this particular striver. Sixth in IndieWire's critics poll and among the year's best-reviewed American films.
Clint Bentley · Drama · ★ 7.3
Joel Edgerton, Felicity Jones, Nathaniel Arcand
Adapted from Denis Johnson's novella, Clint Bentley's film follows a day labourer through the logging camps and rail crews of the early twentieth century American West, and through a grief he never quite names. Joel Edgerton carries it almost wordlessly. A quiet film about how a life is mostly weather and work — and it placed seventh in IndieWire's poll on exactly that quiet.
Chloé Zhao adapts Maggie O'Farrell's novel about the death of Shakespeare's son and the marriage that had to survive it. Jessie Buckley won Best Actress for a performance built from physical grief rather than speeches. The final movement — a play watched by the woman it was written for — is the most emotionally direct sequence in any mainstream film this year.
Seventeen children leave their houses at 2:17 in the morning and run into the dark. Zach Cregger splits the aftermath into overlapping chapters, each one recasting what you thought you had seen, and Amy Madigan won a Supporting Actress Oscar — a rarity for horror. Eighth on the Sight & Sound poll, and the year's most successful marriage of studio horror to formal mischief.
Mascha Schilinski · Drama, War · ★ 6.9
Luise Heyer, Lena Urzendowsky, Claudia Geisler-Bading
Four girls, four generations, one farmhouse in northern Germany. Mascha Schilinski cuts between eras until the century begins to rhyme and the inherited fears of the women in one family become a single continuous sound. Formally the most ambitious German film in years, with a Metascore of 90, and one that trusts its audience to assemble it.
Bi Gan · Sci-Fi, Drama · ★ 7.2
Jackson Yee, Shu Qi, Mark Chao
Bi Gan moves through a century of cinema as though through rooms in a dream: a monster who must not sleep, a world in which dreaming has been outlawed, and a sequence of set pieces that pastiche silent film, noir and much else. It is showing off, gloriously. Tenth on the Sight & Sound poll and the most beautiful object released this year.
Park Chan-wook · Comedy, Crime, Thriller · ★ 7.5
Lee Byung-hun, Son Ye-jin, Park Hee-soon
A paper-mill lifer is laid off and works out that the quickest route back into employment is removing the competition. Park Chan-wook's adaptation of Donald Westlake's novel is a comedy about the violence of the labour market, landing its jokes and its throat-punches with identical precision. A Metascore of 86 and a satire that is funniest exactly when it is most frightening.
Jim Jarmusch · Comedy, Drama · ★ 6.4
Tom Waits, Adam Driver, Mayim Bialik
Three loosely linked panels of adult children visiting their parents, in which almost nothing happens — the joke and the ache both. Jim Jarmusch won the Golden Lion at Venice for a film about the specific awkwardness of loving people you no longer live with, with Tom Waits, Adam Driver and Charlotte Rampling among the visitors. Deadpan, generous, and slyly the year's saddest comedy.
Radu Jude · Comedy, Drama · ★ 6.6
Eszter Tompa, Gabriel Spahiu, Adonis Tanța
A bailiff carries out an eviction in Cluj, the evicted man dies, and Radu Jude spends the rest of the film following her guilt through a Romania busy explaining why nobody is responsible. Shot fast and cheap, talky, furious and very funny — thirteenth on the Sight & Sound poll and the sharpest political film of the year.
Harry Lighton · Romance, Drama, Comedy · ★ 6.4
Harry Melling, Alexander Skarsgård, Lesley Sharp
A timid traffic warden (Harry Melling) is taken up by a biker (Alexander Skarsgård) and enters a submissive relationship the film treats with startling matter-of-factness — a romance with rules rather than a scandal. Harry Lighton's debut is funny about desire without ever sneering at it, and one of the year's most humane love stories.
Julia Loktev · Documentary · ★ 7.2
Anna Nemzer, Ksenia Mironova, Sofya Groysman
Julia Loktev spent months with young journalists at Russia's last independent newsrooms in the weeks before the invasion of Ukraine, filming the moment their work became impossible. At more than five hours it is a chronicle rather than an argument, and after One Battle After Another the highest-rated film of the year on Metacritic. Exhausting, essential, impossible to unsee.
Dea Kulumbegashvili · Drama · ★ 6.8
Ia Sukhitashvili, Kakha Kintsurashvili, Merab Ninidze
Dea Kulumbegashvili's second feature follows an obstetrician in rural Georgia who performs illegal abortions and is investigated after a delivery goes wrong. The style is austere to the point of confrontation — long takes, weather, silence — and refuses to sentimentalise a woman it equally refuses to condemn. Among the most rigorous pieces of direction anywhere this year.
Richard Linklater · Music, History, Drama · ★ 6.6
Ethan Hawke, Bobby Cannavale, Andrew Scott
One night in 1943, in a bar, while Oklahoma! triumphs across the street and the lyricist Lorenz Hart talks himself hoarse about everything except the thing that is killing him. Richard Linklater's chamber piece is almost entirely dialogue and better for it, with Ethan Hawke giving a portrait of a wit who has outlived his own moment.
Kathryn Bigelow · Thriller, Drama · ★ 6.4
Idris Elba, Rebecca Ferguson, Gabriel Basso
Kathryn Bigelow returns with a procedural about the eighteen minutes between the detection of an incoming missile and the decision nobody wants to make, replayed from several rooms along the chain of command. Less interested in spectacle than in the terrifying banality of protocol. Twenty-first on the Sight & Sound poll and the most sobering studio film of the year.
Kaouther Ben Hania · Drama, History · ★ 8.0
Hind Rajab, Motaz Malhees, Saja Kilani
Kaouther Ben Hania builds her film around the real recorded phone calls of a five-year-old girl trapped in a car in Gaza and the Red Crescent volunteers trying to reach her. Keeping the actual voice makes it almost unbearable and completely unanswerable. It won the Grand Jury Prize at Venice; there is nothing else like it this year.
Albert Serra · Documentary · ★ 6.9
Andrés Roca Rey, Roberto Domínguez, Francisco Manuel "Viruta" Durán
Albert Serra follows the bullfighter Andrés Roca Rey from hotel room to ring and back, close enough to hear the muttering, and declines to tell you what to think about any of it. The result is a documentary about ritual, vanity and physical courage that plays like anthropological horror. Metascore 85.
Richard Linklater · Comedy, Drama, History · ★ 7.2
Guillaume Marbeck, Zoey Deutch, Aubry Dullin
Linklater's second entry on this list restages the making of Breathless in 1959 Paris: Godard improvising, the crew despairing, cinema being casually reinvented by people who mostly appear to be having a nice time. Shot in the style of the thing it depicts, it is an unusually unpretentious film about a pretentious moment, and a love letter that never turns soppy.
How this list was made
Titles were cross-referenced across the Sight & Sound critics' poll (more than 100 international critics), IndieWire's annual critics survey (148 critics), Metacritic's Metascore ranking, Rotten Tomatoes' critic consensus, and the results of the Cannes, Venice and Berlin film festivals and the 98th Academy Awards. Ordering reflects combined critical standing across those sources, not box office. Cast, crew, genre and release dates are verified against TMDB. No adult titles are included.
No comments yet — be the first.