25 records that survived every list and poll of the year
CE
Caleido Editorial Team25 июля 2026 г.18 мин чтения0 просмотров
2025 was the year the centre of gravity moved. Bad Bunny's DeBÍ TiRAR MáS FOToS topped Metacritic with a 97, took six Grammy nominations and then won Album of the Year — the first primarily Spanish-language record ever to do it. Rosalía's LUX, an orchestral, multilingual art-pop record that has almost nothing in common with her earlier work, matched its Metascore and led NPR's list. Neither was recorded with the American mainstream in mind.
Beneath that, the critics' consensus went somewhere else entirely. Pitchfork's number one was Los Thuthanaka, an Andean-electronic project almost nobody outside the magazine's readership had heard of; its number two was Dijon's Baby, a blown-out, hand-made R&B record. The overlap between the popular verdict and the critical one was smaller this year than usual, and this list tries to honour both.
Rock had its best year in a decade — Geese, Wednesday, Deftones, Suede, Black Country New Road and Swans all made records that placed high on general lists rather than genre ones. Hip-hop was extraordinarily deep: Clipse reunited after sixteen years, Earl Sweatshirt made a career best, billy woods and MIKE kept the underground ahead of the majors. And pop split between maximalism (Lady Gaga, Sabrina Carpenter) and something stranger and more inward (Addison Rae, PinkPantheress, Lorde).
Albums are dated by first release, which is how Caleido dates them — a couple of records that appeared on 2025 lists came out in late 2024 and are not here.
Use the checklist below to track what you have heard.
Bad Bunny · bomba, caribbean music, chillwave · ★ 4.0
Released on 5 January and still the record of the year twelve months later. Bad Bunny builds it out of plena, bomba and salsa rather than the reggaeton that made him famous, and turns an album about Puerto Rican displacement into the first primarily Spanish-language Album of the Year winner in Grammy history. A Metascore of 97, and a genuine argument about what a pop star owes home.
Thirteen languages, an orchestra, and a concept built around female mystics and sainthood. Rosalía abandons the club entirely and the gamble pays off: a Metascore of 97 and NPR's album of the year. It is closer to contemporary classical than to Motomami, and it is the most ambitious pop record anyone released this decade.
Los Thuthanaka · experimental rock, indigenous andean music, latin electronic
Pitchfork's album of the year, and the one nobody saw coming: Andean instrumentation and Bolivian musical inheritance run through electronics by two brothers working largely outside any scene. It is dense, ceremonial and occasionally overwhelming — the sort of record that wins a critics' poll and then quietly changes what the next few years sound like.
Dijon · alternative r&b, bedroom pop, glitch pop · ★ 2.0
Recorded loose and left deliberately ragged — clipped mics, room noise, takes that fall apart and keep going. Dijon has been the producer's producer for years; this is the record where his own songs finally match the reputation. Pitchfork number two, Metascore 94, and the most physically present R&B album of the year.
The rock record of the year by acclamation. Cameron Winter sings like somebody being wrestled to the ground and the band swings between blues collapse and something close to gospel. Accessible enough to convert people and strange enough to reward the fifth listen — top ten on nearly every major list.
Wednesday · alternative country, english, me 25–10 · ★ 4.0
Karly Hartzman writes Southern detail — the specific brand of soda, the specific humiliation — over guitars that keep tipping into shoegaze noise. Wednesday's fifth album is heavier than Rat Saw God and more exposed, and it placed sixth on Pitchfork's list.
Oklou · alt-pop, alternative pop, alternative r&b · ★ 3.8
Weightless, digitally processed pop that sounds like it is being remembered rather than performed. The French producer's debut proper turns the hyperpop toolkit toward something soft and unresolved, and Pitchfork put it fourth for exactly that refusal to land.
Nourished by Time · alternative r&b, bedroom pop, hypnagogic pop · ★ 3.0
Marcus Brown's one-man Baltimore project scales up without losing the bedroom-recorded warp: eighties soul, new wave bass and lyrics about money, work and romance under conditions that make romance difficult. Ninth on Pitchfork, Metascore 89.
Joanne Robertson · me 26–01, ph_temp_checken · ★ 2.0
Guitar, voice, tape hiss and almost nothing else. Robertson has been making these fragile, half-finished songs for years, and this is the one that converted the critics — Pitchfork ranked it eighth. It sounds like eavesdropping on someone who does not know you are there.
Amaarae sings in a feather-light upper register over Afrobeats, Jersey club, punk guitar and whatever else the song needs. Her third album is the most restless pop record of the year and top ten on Pitchfork — Ghanaian-American music that refuses to sit in any of the boxes offered to it.
Blood Orange · alternative pop, alternative r&b, art pop · ★ 3.0
Dev Hynes's first Blood Orange record in six years, written around his mother's death and the English landscape of his childhood. Guests drift in and out; nothing resolves. A Metascore of 88 and his most emotionally direct work.
billy woods · abstract hip hop, conscious hip hop, drumless · ★ 3.5
A horror album in the strict sense: woods builds the record around racist iconography and the dread of being watched, over production that creaks and drips. It is the most formally committed rap album of the year, and both Pitchfork and Metacritic ranked it near the top.
Earl at his most relaxed and, paradoxically, his sharpest — loops that breathe, verses that stop when they are done. Called a career best by more than one outlet, which for a rapper this consistent is saying something.
Addison Rae · alternative pop, alternative r&b, contemporary r&b · ★ 4.0
The most unlikely critical success of the year: a TikTok celebrity's debut that turned out to be a genuinely strange, Madonna-and-Lana-indebted pop record with real production ideas. Twelfth on Pitchfork, and it retired the joke it started as.
Sudan Archives · alternative r&b, art pop, dance · ★ 3.0
Brittney Parks plays violin like a percussion instrument and raps over the results. Her third album is louder, funnier and more Los Angeles than Natural Brown Prom Queen, and it sits in Pitchfork's top fifteen.
Techno without kick drums, essentially — Sam Barker builds propulsion out of everything except the obvious element. The Berghain resident's second album is the year's most elegant electronic record and the one dance producers will be stealing from.
Perfume Genius · alternative pop, indie pop, me 26–01
Mike Hadreas turns down the theatricality and lets a live band play. The result is his warmest record — Metascore 90 — and proof that the drama in his songs never depended on the production carrying it.
Hayley Williams · alternative pop, bedroom pop, indie rock · ★ 3.6
Released piecemeal online and self-distributed before being assembled into an album, which turns out to suit it: seventeen songs of unedited, unglamorous feeling. The strongest reviews of Williams's solo career, and a Metascore of 91.
Deftones · alternative metal, alternative/indie rock, english · ★ 4.0
Thirty years in and Deftones have made their best-reviewed record: a Metascore of 90 for an album that trusts atmosphere over impact and lets Chino Moreno float above guitars that never quite crash. Heavier bands should study the restraint.
Clipse · gangsta rap, hardcore hip hop, hip hop · ★ 3.8
Pusha T and Malice reunite after sixteen years with Pharrell producing, and the chemistry is intact — Malice's conversion has given the duo a moral argument to have with itself. A Grammy Album of the Year nominee and the comeback record of the decade so far.
caroline · avant-folk, indie rock, post-rock · ★ 3.0
Eight musicians playing post-rock that keeps dissolving into Auto-Tuned choir. The London collective's second album is strange in a way that stays inviting, and it charted on both Pitchfork's and Metacritic's lists.
Nineteen minutes, UK garage and 2000s trance samples, not a second wasted. PinkPantheress's mixtape does more in its runtime than most albums manage in an hour, and it made Pitchfork's top twenty on pure craft.
Smerz · electronic, me 26–01, ph_temp_checken · ★ 3.0
The Norwegian duo make club music with the club removed — half-spoken vocals, classical fragments, beats that arrive late or not at all. Tenth on Pitchfork, and the year's best record about being alone in a crowd.
Mavis Staples at eighty-six, singing about a country she has been correcting since the civil rights movement. A Metascore of 90 for a record that never trades on legacy — the voice is still the argument.
Black Country, New Road · alternative rock, art rock, baroque pop · ★ 3.5
The first proper album since their singer left, with three women now sharing lead vocals and the sound moving toward baroque chamber pop. It could have been a holding pattern; instead it is a reinvention, and the critics treated it as one.
How this list was made
Cross-referenced against Pitchfork's 50 Best Albums of 2025, Metacritic's Metascore ranking of the year's best-reviewed records, the 2026 Grammy Awards results, NPR Music's albums of the year, and genre lists from Rolling Stone, Billboard, Stereogum and Jazzwise. Ordering reflects combined critical standing, not chart position. Artists, titles and release years are verified against MusicBrainz.
Пока нет комментариев — будьте первым.