Ten records from the year guitars stopped apologising
CE
Caleido Editorial Team2026年7月25日閱讀需 10 分鐘0 次瀏覽
For most of the 2010s the rock album was a genre concern that critics covered out of duty. In 2025 it went back to the front of the general lists. Geese's Getting Killed placed top ten on nearly every major poll; Wednesday, Deftones, Suede and Swans all landed high on Metacritic's overall ranking rather than a rock sub-list.
The common thread is bands trusting the room. Geese sound like they are falling apart and catching themselves; caroline put eight players in a space and let the post-rock dissolve into Auto-Tuned choir; Wet Leg swapped deadpan for actual volume. Even Deftones, thirty years in, made their best-reviewed record by letting the guitars hang back.
Two returns matter especially. Black Country, New Road rebuilt themselves without their frontman into a baroque three-vocalist band, and Suede — thirty-two years after their debut — made an album good enough to place ahead of most of the younger competition.
The rock record of the year. Cameron Winter sings like a man being physically restrained while the band lurches between blues collapse and something close to gospel. Immediate enough to convert sceptics, strange enough to survive repeat listening.
Wednesday · alternative country, english, me 25–10 · ★ 4.0
Karly Hartzman's Southern-gothic specifics — the brand names, the small humiliations — pushed into heavier shoegaze than Rat Saw God attempted. The emotional core stays completely exposed underneath the noise.
Alex Giannascoli's major-label debut, and the surprise is how little he sanded down: the pitch-shifted voices and unresolved song structures are intact, just recorded properly. Twenty-third on Pitchfork's list.
Rachel Brown and Nate Amos build songs out of repetition and abrupt tonal swerves, and this is their most listenable set without being their least difficult. Deadpan, mechanical and unexpectedly moving.
caroline · avant-folk, indie rock, post-rock · ★ 3.0
Eight musicians, post-rock guitars, and vocals that keep dissolving into Auto-Tuned choir. The London collective's second album is genuinely strange and never forbidding — a hard balance that almost nobody strikes.
Wet Leg · dance-punk revival, english, garage rock revival · ★ 3.5
The album that answers whether Wet Leg were a novelty: louder, hornier and played by a proper band rather than a duo with session support. The jokes are still there; the guitars now mean it.
Deftones · alternative metal, alternative/indie rock, english · ★ 4.0
Thirty years in and their best-reviewed record — a Metascore of 90 for an album that prioritises atmosphere over impact and lets Chino Moreno drift above riffs that never fully land. Heavy bands should study the restraint.
Suede's tenth album is taut, physical and genuinely angry, which is not what a band thirty-two years past their debut is supposed to sound like. Brett Anderson's late career is one of the strangest success stories in British rock.
The first full album since losing their singer, with three women now sharing the lead and the sound turning toward baroque chamber pop. A reinvention rather than a survival record, and the critics recognised the difference.
Swans · english, experimental rock, post-rock · ★ 4.7
Michael Gira says this is the last Swans record in this configuration, and it is scaled accordingly — long, punishing, occasionally transcendent. A Metascore of 87 for music most people will only survive once.
How this list was made
Compiled from Pitchfork's 50 Best Albums of 2025, Metacritic's Metascore ranking, Rolling Stone's 55 best indie-rock albums of 2025, and BrooklynVegan's Indie Basement year-end list. Artists, titles and release years are verified against MusicBrainz.
尚無留言 — 來搶頭香吧。