How a generation of artists in the 1960s decided that thinking, not making, was the real work of art
Conceptual art is, in the Tate's plain definition, "art for which the idea (or concept) behind the work is more important than the finished art object."[1] It emerged as a recognizable movement in the mid-1960s, and the term most often refers to work made between the mid-1960s and the mid-1970s, although artists have continued to make conceptual work ever since.[1] The shift it proposed was radical: where painting and sculpture had been judged by how they looked, Conceptual art asked to be judged by what it thought. Once the idea took priority, the physical object could become slight, temporary, or even disappear entirely — a tendency the critic Lucy Lippard famously named the "dematerialization" of the art object.[2]
This was not a single style but a set of strategies. A Conceptual work might be a sentence, a photograph, a set of instructions, a performance, or a stack of documents. What unites them is the conviction that the artist's primary medium is thought, and that everything else — paint, marble, gallery walls — is secondary.
Conceptual artists rarely claimed to have invented their position from nothing. Their acknowledged forefather was Marcel Duchamp, who in 1917 submitted a mass-produced porcelain urinal, signed "R. Mutt" and titled Fountain, to the inaugural exhibition of the Society of Independent Artists in New York.[3] By selecting an ordinary manufactured object — what he called a "readymade" — and presenting it as sculpture, Duchamp argued that a work of art should be primarily about the artist's idea rather than the thing itself, and that an object acquired new significance simply by being chosen and displayed by an artist.[3] Tate cites Fountain as an important precedent for Conceptual art, and the principle it dramatized — that art is whatever an artist declares to be art — sat at the foundation of the movement half a century later.[1]
The 1960s gave that idea a name. The term "Conceptual art" was given its first sustained theory in Sol LeWitt's 1967 essay "Paragraphs on Conceptual Art," published in Artforum.[4] LeWitt's opening lines became a manifesto for the whole movement: "In conceptual art the idea or concept is the most important aspect of the work… all of the planning and decisions are made beforehand and the execution is a perfunctory affair. The idea becomes a machine that makes the art."[4] Two years later he expanded the position in "Sentences on Conceptual Art" (1969), a numbered list of aphorisms that remains one of the movement's defining texts.[5]
Several intertwined commitments run through Conceptual art. The first is the primacy of the idea: as LeWitt insisted, planning precedes — and outranks — making.[4] The second is dematerialization. Lippard, who coined the term with John Chandler in an essay written in 1967 and published the following year, used it to describe a period in which the art object became "secondary, lightweight, ephemeral, cheap, unpretentious, and/or 'dematerialized'"; her 1973 book Six Years: The Dematerialization of the Art Object from 1966 to 1972 documented the phenomenon and remains a standard reference for the period.[2]
A third characteristic is the use of language as a medium. Many Conceptual artists treated words, definitions, and instructions as the work itself rather than as a description of it. A fourth is a built-in resistance to the art market: artists associated with the movement attempted to bypass the increasingly commercialized art world by stressing thought processes and methods of production as the value of the work.[1] This last impulse fed directly into what became known as institutional critique — art that turned its attention to the museum, the gallery, and the market as subjects in their own right.[6]
LeWitt put his theory into practice most influentially in his wall drawings, the first of which he produced in 1968.[7] Each work is, essentially, a set of written instructions; the lines are drawn directly onto the wall by draftspeople following the artist's directions.[7] This made literal his belief that the idea, not the hand, is the art. As the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art explains, what a collector or museum actually acquires is "a document prepared by the artist that describes how the works are to be executed," after which the owner takes on the responsibility of hiring the appropriate people to execute it.[8] The same diagram can therefore be executed many times, by different hands, in different places; and because the physical drawing is impermanent — if a wall drawing is relocated, its present form is removed and the piece redrawn in the new location — the work persists as a concept rather than as a single fixed object.[7]
If LeWitt asked what counts as making, Joseph Kosuth asked what counts as art at all. His 1965 work One and Three Chairs presents one chair three ways: an actual wooden folding chair, a full-scale photograph of that chair, and an enlarged dictionary definition of the word "chair."[9] By juxtaposing object, image, and language, the piece interrogates the relationship between a thing, its representation, and its meaning — and because the photograph shows the chair as it is actually installed, the work changes each time it is shown.[9] Kosuth made his program explicit in his 1969 essay "Art after Philosophy," declaring that "being an artist now means to question the nature of art," and that art's only proper subject is the definition of art itself.[10] His formula — art as "idea as idea" — pushed dematerialization toward pure tautology.[1]
Working partly alongside the Fluxus circle, Yoko Ono arrived at a comparable idea from a different direction: the instruction. Her 1964 book Grapefruit gathers more than 150 short "instruction works" — directives addressed to the reader, divided into sections such as Music, Painting, Event, Poetry, and Object — that exist to be imagined or performed rather than displayed.[11] Ono self-published it on July 4, 1964, and it became one of the first of her works acquired by the Museum of Modern Art.[11] The same logic of the score underpins Cut Piece, first performed at the Yamaichi Concert Hall in Kyoto on July 20, 1964, in which Ono sat motionless on stage and invited members of the audience to cut away pieces of her clothing with scissors.[12] By handing authorship to the viewer, Cut Piece is recognized as a pioneering work of participatory performance and one of the earliest and most significant works associated with Fluxus and feminist art.[12]
Conceptual art also reinvented how art was shown. The dealer Seth Siegelaub staged the influential exhibition January 5–31, 1969 in a temporary New York space; it contained no paintings and no sculptures, with physical evidence of the works in one room and a catalogue that Siegelaub treated as the exhibition itself.[13] Among the artists in his orbit was Lawrence Weiner, whose 1968 booklet Statements consisted of twenty-four condensed sentences describing processes, presented as the work with no object required.[6] That same year Weiner issued his "Declaration of Intent," which specified that each of his pieces could be built by him, fabricated by someone else, or "need not be built" at all — leaving the decision, and so the work, to the receiver and the realm of the idea.[6]
Conceptual art's influence has proved enormous and durable. By relocating art's value from the object to the idea, it opened the door to much of what followed — installation, performance, text-based and photographic practice, and the broad field of institutional critique that examines the systems through which art circulates.[1] The artists Tate associates with the movement and its legacy range across generations and continents, from Jenny Holzer and Sophie Calle to Martin Creed and Simon Starling.[1] Lippard's "dematerialization" thesis, once a provocation, now reads as a description of contemporary art's default condition, in which a concept, a process, or a set of instructions can be the finished work.[2] More than half a century on, the central claim of Conceptual art — that thinking is itself a form of making — has been so thoroughly absorbed that it no longer looks like a movement at all, but simply like one of the ways art is now made.
No comments yet — be the first.